Investing is supposed to be a long-term pursuit. Yet it has arguably never been easier to obsess over what is happening right now. We can check our portfolios in seconds, see which funds are at the top of the performance tables and follow every market move as it happens. A few difficult months can suddenly feel like a reason to change course, while the investments currently doing well can quickly become the ones everyone wants to own.
But are we paying too much attention to the short term?
Should you be checking your portfolio every day?
For Georgina Brittain, manager of the JPM UK Smaller Companies fund, there is an important distinction between her job and yours. She needs to pay attention every day. The end investor doesn’t.
“If you’re buying something like my fund, you’re getting access to 80 names, for example, and I look at those every day and make a decision on what to buy and sell. And you as an investor aren’t supposed to look at them every day. I’m supposed to look every day but, as a long-term investor, you shouldn’t be watching your phone thinking, ‘I made 2% today. I lost 3% yesterday.’”
The ability to see exactly what our investments are worth at almost any moment doesn’t necessarily mean it is useful to do so. In fact, Georgina thinks investors could benefit from looking less often.
“I wish people did that less. Not for my sake, for their sake. I think they’d sleep better, they’d be more relaxed, they wouldn’t be jumping in and out trying to be clever and, over time, they’d make more money.”
Is three years even long enough to judge a fund manager?
Zoom out from days to years and there is another problem: how quickly should we decide whether a fund manager is actually good at their job? Jason Pidcock, manager of the Jupiter Asian Income fund, believes investors often overlook one important factor when looking at performance: luck.
His assessment of the role luck plays in fund management: “In the short term, a lot.”
Jason compares fund management with a round of golf. There will be lucky shots and unlucky shots along the way and, given enough time, you’d expect some of that luck to even itself out. The difficulty is deciding how much time is enough.
“You can have a period — it could even be as long as three years — when you’re just lucky. And it looks like you’ve done a good job. And you have, ultimately, because the numbers are what matter. But it was luck that got you there.”
That makes judging a manager on a short burst of strong performance potentially problematic. Equally, a difficult period doesn’t automatically mean the investment process has stopped working. Jason believes investors need a considerably longer record before luck is less likely to distort the picture.
“I would say you probably need a track record of well over five, but ideally over 10 years, where people can say, ‘Okay, over that period, luck probably didn’t play a part.’
“But over a short-term period luck might even be the biggest single factor.”
Jason has been investing in the Asian region for more than three decades and has now managed the Jupiter Asian Income fund for more than 10 years. Over the past decade, the fund has returned 215% to investors, compared with 123% for the average fund in its sector*. So, after more than a decade at the helm, we think it’s probably safe to say there’s more than just luck behind those numbers.

The market is obsessed with the next six months
Short-term thinking isn’t restricted to individual investors. Niko de Walden, manager of the IFSL Pinnacle Life Cycle Global Equity Income fund, believes the market’s own fixation with what happens next can create opportunities for investors willing to look further ahead.
One example in his portfolio is US recreational vehicle manufacturer Thor Industries. Right now, camper vans aren’t an obvious investment success story. “Nobody wants to buy camper vans because interest rates are really high, diesel is really expensive and everyone bought one during Covid,” Niko said.
But Thor has around 40% of its market, according to Niko, and the crucial part of the investment case is what happens beyond today’s difficult environment. Camper vans typically have a five-to-six-year replacement cycle. A huge number were bought during 2020 and 2021, potentially creating replacement demand further down the road. For Niko, this highlights a wider market inefficiency.
“The market is obsessed with what’s going to happen in the next six months. If you’ve got patience and duration, and you can look beyond that, you can find really good businesses that are just not having their moment. The problem is, if you wait until everybody wants to buy camper vans again, the stock might already be up 50%. So you have to buy things when they’re unpopular.”
His approach is then to recycle capital as those investments come back into favour, looking for the next good business that the market currently doesn’t want.
What if an investment is just not having its moment?
There is a common thread running through all three conversations. A day can tell you very little about whether your long-term investment plan is working. A few years of performance may not be enough to establish whether a fund manager’s success is skill or luck. And focusing on the next six months can mean overlooking companies whose prospects may look very different several years from now.
None of that means ignoring poor performance or blindly holding an investment forever. Circumstances change, investment cases break and sometimes selling is absolutely the right decision.
But there is a difference between something changing and simply nothing happening yet. As Niko puts it, sometimes a good business is simply “not having its moment”.
For long-term investors, the challenge is to remain patient and remember that sometimes the greatest regards come to those willing to look beyond the short term.