Which funds make it into the Selection?
When we review the Chelsea Selection, the research team meet to assess the funds currently on the panel against those on our watchlist. Generally, where we feel that a better option is available on the watchlist, we will swap the new fund for the old. However, it should be noted that we prefer not to alter the panel without good reason, as wholesale changes can be confusing for investors. We take the view that long-term performance is important and excessive switching can have a negative impact on performance. Furthermore, in certain circumstances a new fund will be added without removing one e.g. if it covers a sector/region that is not currently incorporated within the Chelsea Selection.
Which funds go into the Core?
The Core Selection, which contains approximately 40 funds, is a more concise version of the Selection, which lists around 100. We choose funds from the Selection which we think should be at the heart of investors’ portfolios. We tend to operate a ‘one in, one out’ policy i.e. a fund can only be added if one is being removed.
Funds are removed where there has been a change of manager, if we have not met and approved the new manager. Also, a removal can be made where there has been persistent underperformance, a change in the mandate, with which we are not happy, or a better offering becomes available. Funds on the Chelsea Core Selection will generally be replaced on a like-for-like basis in all sectors, apart from in the Miscellaneous sector.
In some circumstances where there is no clear choice, a fund may be removed from the Chelsea Core Selection and not replaced until the next edition of Viewpoint, our bi-annual investor magazine. As we aim to retain funds within the Chelsea Core Selection, we prefer not to add them unless we are entirely convinced that they are of sufficient quality to qualify. Furthermore, funds are selected with an eye to retaining diversity within the Chelsea Core Selection i.e. not having too many funds from one provider.